NYC Housing Problems

Welcome to GeoBI Lab

Geospatial insights for intelligent decisions

NYC Private Housing Maintenance Problems

What type of housing maintenance problems current NYC renters are facing?

Data from the city's Housing Preservation Department (HPD) was used to develop interactive Maps and Charts - compiled into a dashboard - with the overall aim to better understand:

- What type of residential maintenance problems New Yorkers deal with and for how long – in 2018 and previous years,

- Where are the critical locations – by city neighborhood,

- Who is most affected? - population segment.

The type of problems that HPD can provide assistance is listed in this report.  Only the private housing sector was considered, all NYCHA public buildings were excluded.

Desktop Only

Maps and charts compiled in a data dashboard.

WHAT problems?

What type of housing maintenance problems are reported to the NYC 311 HPD Service Request? 

# NYC Housing Problems, Types and Sub-types, 2018

* Hoover over graph area to see the number of complaints in 2018.for each problem type. Click on the graph to see sub-classes.

smartphone version:

click on image, rotate to landscape view

The most persistent problems are Hot Water and Heating related issues. In 2018, it accounted for  37% of the total number of complaints, it's also the most persistent problem over time.

Total HPD complaints 2018 = 602,215

# Reported Housing Maintenance Problem by Type, 2010-2018

*Hover over bar chart to see values. Click on graph legend to select particular problem on the graph.

### Note that HPD housing maintenance problem classification was changed in 2014.

click on image

WHERE - Housing Complaints by Neighborhood

The interactive maps show which neighborhoods had the highest complaint rate in 2018.

Map app features:

    ## 2018 Total HPD complaint rate per neighborhood     ## 3 additional maps with the most reported problems in NYC:

Hot Water and Heating, Water Leaks and Mold, Unsanitary conditions as Pests, Sewage and Garbage 

    ## NYC Private Residential Housing Density Map (units per us acre)    ## Search by address- magnifier icon.

** Complaint rate = total HPD complaints per 100 residential household units in one year.

click on map

Location Trend - Problem reporting over time

# Neighborhood Complaint Rate - 2010 to 2018 

click on gif

# Total Complaints per Borough and Year - 2012 to 2018

click on image

WHO - Social Portrait of critical locations

Correlation analysis is an insightful way to determine not cause-effect between complaint intensity and local characteristics, but the relationship strength between them. 

The correlation coefficient is interpreted as r=1: strong relationship, r=0: no relationship

Resident profiling:

- Tenure: Renters with contract rent (r=0.5)
- Average resident Age: 35 to 64 (r=0.5) and 45 to 54 years (r= 0.38)
- Year householder moved into unit: 1990 – 2009 (r=0.4)
- Hispanic or Latino (r=0.43), Black or African American (r= 0.41), Some other race alone (r=0.39)
- Household Income 2015: Less than $10.000 (r=0.4), $10k to 20k (r=0.4), $20k to 40k per year (r=0.4)
- Poverty Status: Household Income in the past year below poverty level (r= 0.4)
- 50% of income goes for rent (r=0.4)

- Gross Rent per month: $1.000 to 1.500 (r=0.4)

Housing characteristics:
- Year Built: 1939 or earlier (r=0.5)
- Household units in building structure: 20 to 49 (r=0.6), more than 50 (r=0.4)

Notes to method: A Spearman correlation analysis was applied between the 2016 ACS  data and Complaint Density (total complaints/total number of residential buildings per CBG). The minimum unit of analysis is at the Census Block Group scale - providing a high level of data detail; the area normally represents 1 to 3 contiguous rows of residential buildings). Population and Housing information was extracted from the best-detailed data source available: the 2016 ACS  Census (with ~3.000 indicators). 

Correlation results, census indicator selection criteria:  correlation coef r>=0.40, with statistical significance p<0.01)

>  About the NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) Complaint Process:  In the case of a maintenance failure from the landlord, residents may require the city HPD to reinforce building or unit maintenance and intervene by the landlord. HPD  sends a notification to the registered owner to advise about the problem and doesn't close the complaint. A call may also be made to the tenant to confirm whether the condition has been corrected. If there is no confirmation of correction by the tenant, an inspector may be dispatched.

Complaints about a housing condition can be filed by calling 311, using 311 online [ ]or filed through the 311 mobile app.


NYC 311  HPD Service Requests - NYC Open Data Portal.

Primary Land Use Tax Lot Output (PLUTO) 

ACS  American Community Survey - 2016 Census estimates

Vanessa Mateus, Geospatial Analyst


Copyright © All Rights Reserved